🚀 Fincover® App is Now Live!
Join 10 Million+ users on web – now available on mobile!
Last updated on: September 24, 2025
The Star Smart Health Pro Plan and Tata AIG Medicare Plan are both popular health insurance options in India, each offering unique features. The Star Smart Health Pro Plan is known for its customizable sum insured options, flexible coverage, and focus on modern treatments, making it ideal for those seeking tailored protection with comprehensive benefits such as day-care treatments and no-claim bonuses. Tata AIG Medicare Plan, on the other hand, emphasizes affordability and extensive network hospitals, providing broad coverage for hospitalization, pre- and post-hospitalization expenses, and optional add-ons like maternity and critical illness cover. While Star’s policy suits individuals wanting personalized coverage and wellness benefits, Tata AIG Medicare is better for those prioritizing extensive cashless networks and competitive premiums. Ultimately, the best plan depends on individual needs, budget, and preferred coverage features.
Author
Read Bio
Reviewed by
Read Bio
Never before has the knowledge of health insurance in India been more significant. As the cost of medicine and the rise in lifestyle diseases and a rising cost of hospitals, a solid health plan is the difference between a good and a bad choice. The Tata AIG Medicare Plan and the Star Smart Health Pro Plan are the two best plans of individual health insurance in the year 2025. They both have their own special features, advantages, and value to various kinds of policy holders. This guide is a comparison between the two plans in detail, discussing the cover, benefits, restrictions, and appropriateness in different customers.
Star Smart Health Pro Plan is a broad based insurance cover of health insurance which is offered to families and individuals and those who are interested in a broader coverage. Star Health has also introduced some new wellness rewards and digital-first claim procedures in 2025 to streamline the customer experience and make it safer. The plan has been tailored to attract both urban and semi-urban policyholders and hence advanced healthcare is made accessible.
Pros:
Cons:
Did you know? Star Health is one of the three leading insurers in terms of claims settlement ratio of retail health policies as per IRDAI data of the early 2025.
Tata AIG Medicare Plan remains to provide comprehensive health cover updated until 2025, which suits the urban Indians seeking digital comfort with strong cover. It has a reputation of offering high levels of claim settlements, customisable features and smooth digital services, which satisfy tech-focused people and the youthful families.
Pros:
Cons:
Expert opinion: It is also advisable that expert reviewer of Tata AIG consider variant specific benefits in the comparison of the Tata AIG because the most popular features might be offered in only Select and Premier plans.
Which Health Plan, either Star Smart Health Pro Plan or Tata AIG Medicare Plan, has better hospital cover?
Star Smart Health Pro Plan provides sum insured of up to Rs 1 crore, whereas the Tata AIG Medicare Select and Premium versions also provide up to 50 lakhs as sum insured. Star Health might be a better choice in case of people who desire ultra-high coverage.
The cost is one of the most important considerations when selecting health insurance plan. The two insurers provide clear and online calculation of premiums according to age, medical history, family size, city, and add-ons. The sample of a 35-year-old, non-smoker, and healthy person in Mumbai in 2025:
| Characteristic | Star Smart Health Pro (Rs 10 lakhs SI) | Tata AIG Medicare Select (Rs 10 lakhs SI) |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Premium | Rs 13,800 | Rs 12,700 |
| None of the claim bonus | Less than 100 percent | Less than 150 percent |
| Room rent capping | yes (up to single private room) 1 | no cap in Select/Premier. |
| Lifetime renewability | Yes | Yes. |
| SI restoration | 100 percent annually | 100 percent indefinitely. |
| Pre hospitalisation | 90 days | 60 days |
| After discharge of the hospital | 180 days | 90 days |
*Sum Insured = SI
Did you know? In 2025, the pre and post-hospitalisation cover of Star Smart Health Pro Plan is in the top category.
It is important to know the exclusion before you conclude a health insurance policy. In 2025, the two insurers have also streamlined their list of exclusions in order to render them easier to comprehend.
Common exclusions in both:
Star Smart Health Pro Plan takes a waiting period on some of its treatments such as joint replacement unless in cases of accidents whereas Tata AIG Medicare does not cover OPD treatments in standard plans.
Does the 2025 cover outpatient and mental care in the plans?
Both offer limited outpatient (OPD) as well as mental health as optional additions, but not in the base policy.
The two plans suit a family well, but there are some significant differences.
Star Smart Health Pro Plan family:
Tata AIG family Medicare Plan:
Professional advice: When the members are above 60, make sure to put a limit on the check room rent as well as co-payment provisions then proceed to choose Tata AIG schemes.
Wellness aspects have been introduced by health insurance providers to align themselves to the current health trends. The rewards of the wellness program of Star Smart Health Pro Plan, including discounted gym memberships and digital fitness points, are redeemed in the form of premium discounts. Tata AIG equally offers policyholders reward in terms of years without claims and routine health check up, although some add-ons are open to nutritional advice.
The benefits to be sought:
Did you know? According to the national surveys in 2025, a greater number of Indian policyholders would choose a plan containing digital health value-adds rather than the traditional policy features.
Social media and online reviews are also influential in the health insurance decision today. Ease of cashless claim on the Star Health and fast reimbursements on the Star Health Pro are well-received in 2025. The immediate payment, particularly of Select and Premier plan of Tata AIG and their hustle-free application are mentioned.
Do planners and emergency hospitalisation vary on claim settlement?
They both provide cashless treatment regardless of planned and emergency hospitalisation on condition that pre-authorisation procedures are adhered to.
Star Smart Health Pro Plan: It is the wellness benefits focused and large family families or want higher sum insured amounts up to Rs 1 crore.
Tata AIG Medicare Plan: The plan is best suited to nuclear families or people who are wishing to have flexibility in terms of add-ons, prefer to have global coverage option or do not like restrictions of room rent.
Think about such aspects as the convenience of hospital network, the automatisation of claims management, and the age of family members prior to selection. Each and every time, review policy wordings with care as minor variations affect the real use in the course of hospitalisation.
Which one is more appropriate among elderly citizens?
Star Smart Health Pro Plan is better fitted when you require ultra-high sum insured and frequent preventive checkups to ageing parents. Tata AIG can be the right choice in case you do not wish to have a room rental limit and online medical services.
Is either of the insurers lifelong renewable?
Tata AIG Medicare and Star Smart Health Pro have a lifetime renewability.
How promptly are pre-existing illnesses covered under such plans?
The two plans tend to cover existing illnesses after 2-3 years although there must be a constant renewal.
Are both cashless hospitalised in the entire country?
Yes, the two insurers are providing cashless treatment in their network hospitals in majority of the Indian states.
How could we improve this article?
Written by Prem Anand, a content writer with over 10+ years of experience in the Banking, Financial Services, and Insurance sectors.
Prem Anand is a seasoned content writer with over 10+ years of experience in the Banking, Financial Services, and Insurance sectors. He has a strong command of industry-specific language and compliance regulations. He specializes in writing insightful blog posts, detailed articles, and content that educates and engages the Indian audience.
The content is prepared by thoroughly researching multiple trustworthy sources such as official websites, financial portals, customer reviews, policy documents and IRDAI guidelines. The goal is to bring accurate and reader-friendly insights.
This content is created to help readers make informed decisions. It aims to simplify complex insurance and finance topics so that you can understand your options clearly and take the right steps with confidence. Every article is written keeping transparency, clarity, and trust in mind.
Based on Google's Helpful Content System, this article emphasizes user value, transparency, and accuracy. It incorporates principles of E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness).
Loved by 1M+ users (web). Start your financial journey today!
